Heater Question

[CammieTime]

I need to get my 29 gallon hospital tank up to 100 degrees when I get a sick fish. Two weeks at that temp seems to solve most issues. Saved my orange fish last March. My current 150W heater cant get the temp higher than 95, what brand or size of heater should I use to get the temp to 100 degrees?

[fishbubbles]

A 250 should easily get that high. I use the eheim Jaeger's in my breeding tanks. Be careful about treating sick fish with high heat though , if the fish is fighting a bacteria infection you will quickly kill it.

[tonytheboss1]

:book: Truthfully a constant 90/95 degrees is more than enough to kill most ickies without super stressing an already weakened ill fish. I too use Eheim Jager w/ Jehmco Controller. "T"

[sanjay21]

:book: Truthfully a constant 90/95 degrees is more than enough to kill most ickies without super stressing an already weakened ill fish. I too use Eheim Jager w/ Jehmco Controller. "T"

+1

[Adam S]

Be careful about treating sick fish with high heat though , if the fish is fighting a bacteria infection you will quickly kill it.
This ^

That being said, I like Aqueon Pro's (old Marineland Stealth's, before they were garbage). Beananimal (the overflow guy) has a nifty formula for calculating heater size:

((Desired temp - room temp)/10) * (tank size in gallons) * (3 watts minimum)

Ex: ((100°F-72°F)/10)*(29 gallons)*(3 watts) = 243.6 watts

[DISCUS STU]

Good luck treating here and I hope it works out for you. High heat can be a double edged sword because anything a bit above 100 f. and you can get fried fish instead of recovery.

Please keep us posted. I haven't used extreme heat therapy in years precisely because I lost two beautiful fish years ago when the heater went a few degrees above 100 f.

[CammieTime]

What I have experienced is that even with a 300W heater in the 29 gallon tank, it will not heat the water beyond the 90 degree ceiling it is designed for. It seems there is a sensor on it that shuts it off if the temp goes above 90 degrees. I need to find a heater that does not do this.

[100fuegos]

It is not only about the size of the heater, you can put a 1000W heater in a 20 G tank and it will not get it above the temp the built in thermostat allows it to. So you need to look the max temp the built in thermostat allows a certain heater to heat the water and then size it according to the criteria mentioned above (water volume and temp difference).

[Adam S]

Most titanium heaters lack an internal thermostat. This let's you hook it up to whatever gizmo you want (Ranco, Inkbird, etc.) at whatever temperature you want.

[HappyFace]

:book: Truthfully a constant 90/95 degrees is more than enough to kill most ickies without super stressing an already weakened ill fish. I too use Eheim Jager w/ Jehmco Controller. "T"

Do you know if plecos and corys can handle 95 degrees? They say plecs are supposed to be at 68-82 degrees F. I've never had my tank over 88.

[Adam S]

Cories? Maybe sterbai, eversi, a couple others. It's not unusual for them to be in the high 80's in the wild, but 95°F is really pushing it.

Plecos, depends on what type. Most hypancistrus should be fine with it, but it's certainly not ideal. Make sure the water has a boiling source of aeration.

What's the goal behind 95°F?

[HappyFace]

Cories? Maybe sterbai, eversi, a couple others. It's not unusual for them to be in the high 80's in the wild, but 95°F is really pushing it.

Plecos, depends on what type. Most hypancistrus should be fine with it, but it's certainly not ideal. Make sure the water has a boiling source of aeration.

What's the goal behind 95°F?

Thank you Adam. I won't go above 90 then. My new discus are stressed with clamped fins. My water parameters are good (zero ammonia, nitrate, nitrite) and I always do 80% w/c daily. After reading this thread I thought maybe raising the temp might help. They're at 86 right now. They have a danner pond pump with this 8"bubbler and the sump waterfall also adds some oxygen.

[CammieTime]

Most titanium heaters lack an internal thermostat.

Where can I get this titanium heater, Amazon?

[LJSmith]

BulkReefSupply has them on sale often. I use kensfish.com and his prices are always great. Sometimes he is out of stock so I go to BulkReef

[Adam S]

I've heard good things about the Finnex titanium heaters but never bothered trying them. I'd start with (this) (https://www.amazon.com/Finnex-Deluxe-Titanium-Heating-Tube/dp/B0199W7368/ref=sr_1_1?s=pet-supplies&ie=UTF8&qid=1515896267&sr=1-1&keywords=finnex+titanium) and a Ranco ETC-111000 controller.

Forgot to ask, what is your room temperature?

[Willie]

I use a titanium heater in my quarantine/hospital tank to bring the temperature up. It can do 100F without getting above that.

Willie

[HappyFace]

I've heard good things about the Finnex titanium heaters but never bothered trying them. I'd start with (this) (https://www.amazon.com/Finnex-Deluxe-Titanium-Heating-Tube/dp/B0199W7368/ref=sr_1_1?s=pet-supplies&ie=UTF8&qid=1515896267&sr=1-1&keywords=finnex+titanium) and a Ranco ETC-111000 controller.

Forgot to ask, what is your room temperature?


I need to get my 29 gallon hospital tank up to 100 degrees when I get a sick fish. Two weeks at that temp seems to solve most issues. Saved my orange fish last March. My current 150W heater cant get the temp higher than 95, what brand or size of heater should I use to get the temp to 100 degrees?

I recommend Finnex. Mine lasted longer than all my other heaters and was also more powerful even though it was the same wattage. Mine went out due to user error not manufacture problem. It came out of the water and fried otherwise I'd still have it. I love their digital controller for regular use. I don't think it goes up to 100 degrees but it had a loud alarm that goes off if the temp gets too high or too low (you set where you want it to be). After my heater went out I still am using the controller as a thermometer and the alarm goes off even without the heating element attached.

Sorry for butting in on your thread with my question yesterday.

[CammieTime]

I use a titanium heater in my quarantine/hospital tank to bring the temperature up. It can do 100F without getting above that.

Willie

What brand and wattage?

[zhuls1]

Thank you Adam. I won't go above 90 then. My new discus are stressed with clamped fins. My water parameters are good (zero ammonia, nitrate, nitrite) and I always do 80% w/c daily. After reading this thread I thought maybe raising the temp might help. They're at 86 right now. They have a danner pond pump with this 8"bubbler and the sump waterfall also adds some oxygen.

Hiedi, raising the temp will only help with internal parasites, if you are not sure what is wrong with the fish I don't think it would be advisable to use heat treatment because if it has a bacterial infection heat tratment could potentially kill your fish. If you haven't done so already, please fill out a disease questionnaire. Also, do you have a microscope? if so this is the best method and only accurate means of identifying parasites or bacterial infection.