200 gal tank what canaster filter would you reccomend?

[Randy-S]

Its going to be a low tech plated tank with about 12 discus in it and some tetras and bottom dwellers.

Looking for silent operation and ease of use.
Thanks

[wheelsdeal]

Hello.200g is a big tank to go with canisters best thing is to go with a sump.If by any reason you cant, i would put 2 big canisters like Eheim pro3 2080 or Fluval FX5 (preferably the Eheim).The number of fish you are considering are more than ok but still i wouldnt go for less than 2 big canisters at this size.

[Randy-S]

Hello.200g is a big tank to go with canisters best thing is to go with a sump.If by any reason you cant, i would put 2 big canisters like Eheim pro3 2080 or Fluval FX5 (preferably the Eheim).The number of fish you are considering are more than ok but still i wouldnt go for less than 2 big canisters at this size.

Thanks for the reply as a matter of fact I already have a sump. This is a converted marine tank. However my sump is not a wet dry filter. So i was thinking of keeping some submerge bio balls in the flow area and keeping the two filter sox's. Its also a great place to hide my heaters .
I leaning toward the fx-5 i can get one on fee bay for under 200
Just not sure how loud they are.

On a side note i was kicking around adding a reverse flow sand filter in my sump just for some added bi filter or just stay with the submerge bio balls Any thoughts?

[wheelsdeal]

You can check here a comparison made between the 2080 and the FX5.

http://www.discusforums.com/forum/viewtopic.php?t=7080&highlight=fx5

[Randy-S]

You can check here a comparison made between the 2080 and the FX5.

http://www.discusforums.com/forum/viewtopic.php?t=7080&highlight=fx5

thank you I will

[Randy-S]

well i read through the post and it did not speak very well of the fluval xl-5

[Darrell Ward]

Its going to be a low tech plated tank with about 12 discus in it and some tetras and bottom dwellers.

Looking for silent operation and ease of use.
Thanks

The sump is going to be a heck of easier to use than a canister. You have to take a dang canister apart to clean them. PITA!

[Jhhnn]

Although I' have no experience with them, I'm intrigued by the Kaldnes media systems for sumps. some discussion of Dale Jordan's system, here-

http://forum.simplydiscus.com/showthread.php?t=79077&highlight=kaldnes&page=10

[Darrell Ward]

Although I' have no experience with them, I'm intrigued by the Kaldnes media systems for sumps. some discussion of Dale Jordan's system, here-

http://forum.simplydiscus.com/showthread.php?t=79077&highlight=kaldnes&page=10

So am I. I've been sitting here trying to figure out how I could make this work on my 55 gal. sump. Do you know if Dale Jordan uses mechnical before the Kaldnes bio? I'm still trying to figure this out in my head. :undecided:

[chagoi]

Hi I have a 180 with a Nu clear canister (not Ocean Clear) filter.The tank is in my liveingroom wall and i can't hear it. It's been going for over 10 years . I have 2 inline in my QT one 25 sq ft cartridge then a 40 sq ft. What I like is you add the pump. Each tank has a over head wet dry. Cleaning any canister is a job if have a small load the sump may be better.

[DonMD]

I also have a large tank, tho not 200, it's a 125. Two Eheim filters, one a 2028, the other a 2026. Totally silent. Easy to clean.

[Randy-S]

I went with the fluval xl5 so far so good I also have a sump on the tank.
I used small bio balls to fill the two chambers in the fluval and left one to change around as I see fit.
Currently the third chamber has charcol to remove the tannans from my drift wood.

[West1]

I have nothing but positive for FX5
FX5 and Sump should do the trick for you :D
Any pics?

[Randy-S]

of the tank I have not taken any but I think i should I am waiting until Jan to add my discus
I have already decided I will be getting them from Kenny. I have been chatting with him via email and drooling over his updates.

[Randy-S]

Since you asked here are a couple of pics no discus yet.

http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v349/ranran/Discus%20tank/Discustank002.jpg
http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v349/ranran/Discus%20tank/Discustank001.jpg
http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v349/ranran/Discus%20tank/Discustank003.jpg

and the sump fx5 and ranco controller running a 500 watt heater. I use a pinpoint wireless thermoeter on my desk to keep an eye on my temp

http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v349/ranran/Discus%20tank/Discustank004.jpg

[josephl]

Very nice tank. I have a 240 gallon with 2 FX 5's as filteration and love them.

[Kingdom Come Discus]

Fluvl fx5 hands down.

[skerzfan]

I'd recommend a Eheim 2262.

[puntific]

Randy, where's all the salt creep?

puntific

[Marowana]

nice tank.
it not that diffcult to convert your sump to a wet dry if you want to. but i think you'll need to fill up your sump with more filter floss and bio media. have you ever thought about using plastic pot scrubbers instead of bio-balls?

[Randy-S]

nice tank.
it not that diffcult to convert your sump to a wet dry if you want to. but i think you'll need to fill up your sump with more filter floss and bio media. have you ever thought about using plastic pot scrubbers instead of bio-balls?

The local reefers had plenty of free bioballs for me so I just added them to a section of my sump. Its noys a trickle filter but a high flow area. So i did add more bio material.
The fx5 i have two chambers filled with bio max and the third is just for mech filtration.