Protein Skimmer Question

[DiscusLoverJeff]

Hello friends,

Would it be practical to replace my Remora C (which does not seem to be doing anything anymore even with a new pump) and get Reef Octopus® BH2000 HOB skimmer with external OTP 2000 pump and keep my AquaClear 70 for filtration or is the OTP 2000 overkill for a 50 gallon reef and just go with the OTP 1000? Figure for $20.00 more the pump size is double at 500gph as to the 250 gph on the OTP 1000.

I was thinking of converting a 20 gallon wet/dry into a sump with live rock and sand and get an in-sump skimmer. I can also attach a 30 gallon refugium to the sump as well but that too may just be overkill but the volume of water exchanging would be near 100 gallons. Again, could be overkill.

I was also going to replace the AquaClear 70 with a Rena XP canister for more forced water movement throughout the reef as opposed to 3 powerheads that I am using now. I can add a spray-bar to the Rena to cover most of the surface of the tank.

Any thoughts or comments would be appreciated. But right now my skimmer is the main thing I need to get going right now as the reef not getting the proper skimming anymore and I don't want to cause too many issues.

Thanks,

Jeff

[darcy]

You can overkill a skimmer with no problems. I'd steer clear of a canister filter,unless your just moving water through it with no media in it. They are nitrate factory's with media in them. I run a 90 with 20 gallon sump and have 2 Koralia powerheads. Lots of liverock is my filter!!

[DiscusLoverJeff]

Thats what I was thinking of doing to Darcy, I have about 20 lbs of rock clean and ready to use.

The canister can be filled with pieces of live rock and sponges like a sump and easier to clean, but the sump can hold my skimmer and heater too.

[darcy]

Jeff
don't put sponges in there man!! BAD!!! Been there done that type of deal,it will cause you heartbreak down the road!

[darcy]

Double post,sorry about that!

[DiscusLoverJeff]

Hmm, I seen some "reefers" discussing using poret foam in their canisters with 1" pieces of live rock. Will find that thread and review it.

Thanks Darcy!

[a volar]

There's nothing better than a sump, get the bigest you can put inside stand.

[Second Hand Pat]

Jeff, when I had my reef setup a overlarge skimmer and a sump was all that was needed. If you decide on a in sump skimmer make sure the sump can handle the footprint (plus pump) of the skimmer. I had a three chamber sump, one of the inlet with fine mesh bags, one for the skimmer and third chamber for the pump return. I would personally not have a canister filter. I do not see the need. As for flow I found with the rock structure in the tank I needed the pumps so the flow could be customized around the rock structure.

http://forum.simplydiscus.com/showth...cus-I-Had-This

[DiscusLoverJeff]

Any pictures of your sump Pat?

I have a few options for a sump. I have a 30 gallon with 2 sections (can easily add a third). I have the 30 gallon Refugium and I have the wet/dry that has small sections in it for general purposes.

My reef has been running good for 3 years now, but it is all of a sudden developing algae issues and phosphate issues. But I would like to increase the water volume and move the equipment to a sump for sure.

wetdry.jpg

wetdry2.jpg

[Second Hand Pat]

Here you go Jeff. This picture were leak testing prior to insertion into the stand



and in the stand. Skimmer was in the first chamber. I am using this sump on a discus tank today.

[DiscusLoverJeff]

Thanks Pat for the pics. I like the design. In the first pic, where did you get the filter socs that I see?

[Second Hand Pat]

LFS Jeff but they are cheaper online.

[Dogvet06]

Hmm I've had my protein skimmer on my reef shut off bc I never could get it quiet. I've been fighting with severe algae growth for a while too. Guess I need to get it going again


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[DiscusLoverJeff]

Yeah Jaimie thats my problem, even after adding a new pump and adjust the airflow it still not doing much. I tried cleaning out the system and ports but still not much collecting in the cup. And, because of that, my algae is getting a bit out of control.

[Dogvet06]

yeah my tank looks like the tank on finding nemo after he put the rock in the filter and all the walls were covered in algae. i scrape it off and its back the next day. im about ready to sell the whole thing bc im tired of seeing a wall of green