ChicagoDiscus.com     Cafepress Store

Page 1 of 2 12 LastLast
Results 1 to 15 of 19

Thread: Group study - Optimizing discus growth

  1. #1
    Registered Member Argentum's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2013
    Location
    Saudi Arabia
    Posts
    606

    Default Group study - Optimizing discus growth

    Hello everyone,

    Note: it is not the intention of this thread to discus the presence, absence or effect of of the so called GLH. The objective is to design a systematic study to test different variables that contribute to the growth of fish in general and come up with the best practice to do so.

    I recently revived an old thread about GLH, and after reading several ones. And a point was raised several times that Discus had not been researched in an extensive way like other farming species where there is money ie: Tilapia, salmon ... etc.

    So why not do it our selves, it is very difficult for one individual to do it on his own, however combined we can work it out.
    Many of us have multiple tanks, breeding tanks and grow out tanks, an most importantly breeding pairs.

    Why do we need to do so?

    There are many reasons, it can save us money, time and effort we spend on growing out discus to get them to the large sizes.

    What are the factors that we need to study?
    There are many factors and to study the effect of one of theses factors all other factors should be fixed.
    Important points that need to be studied are:
    1- Stocking density
    2- Amount of food (usually measured in % of weight)
    3- Amount of water to be changed
    4- Water temperature
    5- Illumination time
    6- Diet composition
    7- Other factors ... you can suggest

    Who can do it?
    An one who has the resources and is willing to commit for a 3 months period recording and sharing his findings.

    How will the experiment be designed?

    In every study all the above factors should have a default value that will be agreed on. Then only the variable that is being studied should be changed. The study should be applied on a single group of discus from the same batch & parents. divided randomly into 3 or 4 groups (depending on how many different values you are going to test)

    An example
    Lets say we are studying the illumination time, and you want to see the effect of zero, 12, 18 & 24 hours of illumination per day.

    So you will get a batch of fry divide them into 4 groups lets say 15 each (the larger the better), feed them 4 times daily, change 25% of the water daily, using only one type of food at 28 C.

    The rate of growth will be measured at a set frequency for a period of three months and then statistical tools will be used to evaluate the results. It is best to repeat the same experiment 3 times to get a measure of the RSD.

    So who is in? What are your thoughts?

  2. #2
    Registered Member Argentum's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2013
    Location
    Saudi Arabia
    Posts
    606

    Default Re: Group study - Optimizing discus growth

    One more thing I want to add is, the layout I laid for the study is just provisional, and is for discussion.

  3. #3
    Registered Member
    Join Date
    Sep 2014
    Location
    Winnetka CA
    Posts
    549
    Real Name
    Kris

    Default Re: Group study - Optimizing discus growth

    This kind of experiment is difficult to do outside of a single roof for a few reasons...

    Each person involved probably has different tap water conditions that will affect the results.

    As far as stocking, density aside, all tests need to use fish that are as similar as possible, so essentially a single large batch of fry would need to be split among the participants, difficult to do really.

    Food mixes also are an issue because no single batch of food is the same really.

    But, I can pretty much tell where the results would wind up going... Given that the tanks of fish are practically the same, the tank that is fed the most and has the most frequent 100% water changes daily will win, followed closely by the tank that is fed half as much with the same frequency of water changes as power feeding dives deep into the land of diminishing returns.

    Temperature may play a small factor in the metabolism, but if the fish are already eating huge amounts, this is probably negligible and should not exceed 86F for risk of fish getting sick.

    There was a grow out contest somewhere here before, i believe that's where much info was obtained.

  4. #4
    Registered Member nc0gnet0's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2010
    Location
    Grand Rapids, MI
    Posts
    8,054
    Real Name
    Rick

    Default Re: Group study - Optimizing discus growth

    There are many reasons, it can save us money, time and effort
    Any system that would do so would be wrought with compromises, it is after all, the time and effort that will ultimately make the biggest impact.
    Ex-President-North American Discus Association-NADA
    [SIGPIC][/SIGPIC]

  5. #5
    Registered Member nc0gnet0's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2010
    Location
    Grand Rapids, MI
    Posts
    8,054
    Real Name
    Rick

    Default Re: Group study - Optimizing discus growth

    3 months is not an adequate amount of time.
    Ex-President-North American Discus Association-NADA
    [SIGPIC][/SIGPIC]

  6. #6
    Registered Member Argentum's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2013
    Location
    Saudi Arabia
    Posts
    606

    Default Re: Group study - Optimizing discus growth

    Quote Originally Posted by kris2341 View Post
    This kind of experiment is difficult to do outside of a single roof for a few reasons...

    Each person involved probably has different tap water conditions that will affect the results.

    As far as stocking, density aside, all tests need to use fish that are as similar as possible, so essentially a single large batch of fry would need to be split among the participants, difficult to do really.

    Food mixes also are an issue because no single batch of food is the same really.

    But, I can pretty much tell where the results would wind up going... Given that the tanks of fish are practically the same, the tank that is fed the most and has the most frequent 100% water changes daily will win, followed closely by the tank that is fed half as much with the same frequency of water changes as power feeding dives deep into the land of diminishing returns.

    Temperature may play a small factor in the metabolism, but if the fish are already eating huge amounts, this is probably negligible and should not exceed 86F for risk of fish getting sick.

    There was a grow out contest somewhere here before, i believe that's where much info was obtained.
    I agree with you that the tank receiving the most WC and most feeding will most probably have the best outcome, however when conducting such studies there is a certain point where the rate of growth will reach a maximum and further increase in the variable will not yield any increase in growth.

    This is the point we are trying to identify. by doing this no extra wasted effort shall be spent. I say wasted because extra food water change water volume beyond that point will give no return in fish growth

  7. #7
    Registered Member nc0gnet0's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2010
    Location
    Grand Rapids, MI
    Posts
    8,054
    Real Name
    Rick

    Default Re: Group study - Optimizing discus growth

    I really hate to bust your bubble, and there is nothing wrong with a good experiment, but I feel you may be better served by simply polling the people here that routinely breed good quality large fish, asking them there methods etc etc. All of these will have played with or tweaked many of the questions you have asked.

    To partake in your experiment would mean sacrificing large portions of batches of fry, subjecting them to substandard conditions, and ending up with sub quality fish.
    Ex-President-North American Discus Association-NADA
    [SIGPIC][/SIGPIC]

  8. #8
    Registered Member Argentum's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2013
    Location
    Saudi Arabia
    Posts
    606

    Default Re: Group study - Optimizing discus growth

    Quote Originally Posted by nc0gnet0 View Post
    3 months is not an adequate amount of time.
    I suggested this a random number based on its repetition in several tilapia publications, What time frame do you thing is more effective?

    But keep in mind that at this stage of a study, you are optimizing. After we obtain these optimum parameters it will open the door to get more insight on different methods of growing discus.

    For instance, effect of size segregation on the growth under optimum parameters or the change in the rate of growth at different ages when using these optimum parameters.

    I am not new to using the scientific method I worked in several analytical chemistry research projects, and is working at the moment developing analytical methods for a petrochemical QC lab. I am not implying that everything I say is correct just saying that I am familiar with designing experiments.

    So trust me it can be done. And having the fry from different parents when testing different parameters is okay since they in that particular experiment are a fixed parameter.

  9. #9
    Registered Member Argentum's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2013
    Location
    Saudi Arabia
    Posts
    606

    Default Re: Group study - Optimizing discus growth

    Quote Originally Posted by nc0gnet0 View Post
    I really hate to bust your bubble, and there is nothing wrong with a good experiment, but I feel you may be better served by simply polling the people here that routinely breed good quality large fish, asking them there methods etc etc. All of these will have played with or tweaked many of the questions you have asked.

    To partake in your experiment would mean sacrificing large portions of batches of fry, subjecting them to substandard conditions, and ending up with sub quality fish.
    This is true, and it's a price that I believe it is worth it.

    If those people are willing to share their tips and tricks, I am here to learn. However, I believe you agree that things are different when approached in a systematic way. Because those people often will have avoided to try some things out of speculation thinking that it may stunt their fish

  10. #10
    Registered Member nc0gnet0's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2010
    Location
    Grand Rapids, MI
    Posts
    8,054
    Real Name
    Rick

    Default Re: Group study - Optimizing discus growth

    Discus growth will typically take more than a year, with your experiment which period are you targeting, and how will you know at the end of three months, that what appears to have been a success at that stage, might not in fact be a reason for the end result (after 15 months) being a substandard fish?
    Ex-President-North American Discus Association-NADA
    [SIGPIC][/SIGPIC]

  11. #11
    Registered Member Argentum's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2013
    Location
    Saudi Arabia
    Posts
    606

    Default Re: Group study - Optimizing discus growth

    Quote Originally Posted by nc0gnet0 View Post
    Discus growth will typically take more than a year, with your experiment which period are you targeting, and how will you know at the end of three months, that what appears to have been a success at that stage, might not in fact be a reason for the end result (after 15 months) being a subs sure whtandard fish?
    I am not quiet sure at what stage should the experiment start, as with discus having a complex parenting behavior which will vary depending on the pair them self. Maybe after reaching 2 cm size being fed Artemia the period before that.Then start feeding a BH mix including the same ingredients with the beginning of the study. What do you think?

    And your second point is very valid, but I don't know if it's possible to have a set of conditions that will work for juvies but not for adults.
    I think these are the things we are going to discover. What do you thing again?

  12. #12
    Registered Member nc0gnet0's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2010
    Location
    Grand Rapids, MI
    Posts
    8,054
    Real Name
    Rick

    Default Re: Group study - Optimizing discus growth

    What do I think? I think raising discus is more of an art form than it is a science. Parameters are constantly changing, and each scenario needs it's own tweaks. What works for one person may not work for the next. People will look at your results and only incorporate the easy stuff, most often with disastrous results. For instance, you might decide that feeding 3" fish 6x a day and doing 5x water changes of 85% or better is the ultimate.

    And what will people take from this? Feed discus 6x a day.....but will they do the required water changes? Hell no. Welcome to the world of human nature, were everyone wants instant, easy results, and are not prepared to put the time in to achieve it.

    End result-dead or sickly fish.

    I will share with you what I have learned. Growing out discus is not a race, it's a passion. The ABSOLUTE most important parameter is clean water and lots of it. Tailor your feeding schedule around your water changes, and adjust how much you feed accordingly. I might feed one amount on weekdays do to time constraints, and increase this amount on weekends when I can change more water. I may adjust what I feed one day when I know my time might be limited, etc etc.

    I could care less if my discus at 6 months are 4" or 6", what I care about is how they look at the end of their growth cycle, and if they have reached their full potential.
    Ex-President-North American Discus Association-NADA
    [SIGPIC][/SIGPIC]

  13. #13
    Registered Member Rudustin's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2012
    Location
    Miami Beach, Florida
    Posts
    1,731

    Default Re: Group study - Optimizing discus growth

    I could care less if my discus at 6 months are 4" or 6", what I care about is how they look at the end of their growth cycle, and if they have reached their full potential. I so agree with this statement.

  14. #14
    Registered Member Argentum's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2013
    Location
    Saudi Arabia
    Posts
    606

    Default Re: Group study - Optimizing discus growth

    Quote Originally Posted by nc0gnet0 View Post
    And what will people take from this? Feed discus 6x a day.....but will they do the required water changes? Hell no. Welcome to the world of human nature, were everyone wants instant, easy results, and are not prepared to put the time in to achieve it.

    End result-dead or sickly fish. .
    They should learn the hard way then, thats what happens when you apply half the advice

    Quote Originally Posted by nc0gnet0 View Post
    I will share with you what I have learned. Growing out discus is not a race, it's a passion. The ABSOLUTE most important parameter is clean water and lots of it. Tailor your feeding schedule around your water changes, and adjust how much you feed accordingly. I might feed one amount on weekdays do to time constraints, and increase this amount on weekends when I can change more water. I may adjust what I feed one day when I know my time might be limited, etc etc.

    I could care less if my discus at 6 months are 4" or 6", what I care about is how they look at the end of their growth cycle, and if they have reached their full potential.
    Thank you for sharing thats what I am doing which I learned from you from previous discussions

    I still need to conduct these studies, they might be a way to the ultimately best Discus at the end of their growth cycle.... but we just don't know it because it's outside of our comfort zone.

    I feel I am determined to start experimenting with this, if anyone want's to share he's most welcome

  15. #15
    Registered Member timmy82's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 2012
    Location
    Sunshine Coast (Nth)
    Posts
    761
    Real Name
    Tim Allen

    Default Re: Group study - Optimizing discus growth

    Quote Originally Posted by nc0gnet0 View Post
    What do I think? I think raising discus is more of an art form than it is a science. Parameters are constantly changing, and each scenario needs it's own tweaks. What works for one person may not work for the next. People will look at your results and only incorporate the easy stuff, most often with disastrous results. For instance, you might decide that feeding 3" fish 6x a day and doing 5x water changes of 85% or better is the ultimate.

    And what will people take from this? Feed discus 6x a day.....but will they do the required water changes? Hell no. Welcome to the world of human nature, were everyone wants instant, easy results, and are not prepared to put the time in to achieve it.

    End result-dead or sickly fish.

    I will share with you what I have learned. Growing out discus is not a race, it's a passion. The ABSOLUTE most important parameter is clean water and lots of it. Tailor your feeding schedule around your water changes, and adjust how much you feed accordingly. I might feed one amount on weekdays do to time constraints, and increase this amount on weekends when I can change more water. I may adjust what I feed one day when I know my time might be limited, etc etc.

    I could care less if my discus at 6 months are 4" or 6", what I care about is how they look at the end of their growth cycle, and if they have reached their full potential.
    Alot of truths here thanks Rick.
    It would be more viable to take this to the breeding farms ect in Asia and pool some results that way. There are so many varriables in a hobbiest scheme of things and not everyone is prepaired to be truthful in their documentation.
    My routine varries depending on my full time job work load too. Clean water and good food I seem to get fry to 3" in 3 months and 6" in 12 - 16 months. But saying that I have an F1 snow leopard that is 11 months and 6" last time he was out so would be thinking another 6 months should add an inch or two? Time will tell.
    Thanks Timmy
    [SIGPIC][/SIGPIC] Follow me on FaceBook Time Bomb Discus
    https://www.facebook.com/#!/groups/213399702163350/
    Or all enquiries timebombdiscus@outlook.com.au

Page 1 of 2 12 LastLast

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •  

Cafepress