Personal choice between golden pigeon or rose discus

[we4wieners]

I am finishing up my stocking with either one of these two. The golden are all white and gold, very pretty. The rose is a bright deep red fish, gorgeous. My current stocking is red pigeons, blue turqs, marlboros, blue diamonds, and golden leopards.
I know it's personal choice, but what would you do? Just curious. There both around 6".

[ockyra215]

Both of them!

[rickztahone]

Love the rose reds and that is what I would go for personally.

[we4wieners]

I would love both, but my driving would be to much. Iam leaning torward the rose as well.

[Rudustin]

I have four rose reds, two San Merahs, three curiperaXs that red with blue marking. So you know what I would choose!

[rickztahone]

show the picks and I'm sure you will pursuade

[we4wieners]

Trying to get pics now from seller. I've seen them in person. Both are beautiful. Think I really want that deep red in my tank. Ill post once I pick him up tomorrow evening.

[Keith Perkins]

Rose Red

[DISCUS STU]

They're both great. I'd go for the Gold!

[Crockett]

Rose Red for me , not even close. IMO they are just beautiful and my second favorite strain after the Fiamma Rossa (Super Tropical Red)

[Lilly]

Did you get the new fish?

[pastry]

I dream of a tank full of rose reds & other brown-based reds. Really hope you go with RR's. Would love seeing pictures

[Rudustin]

I have Rose Red, Blushing Reds, San Merahs, Curipera X's, Albino Golden Melons and Golden Melons. They are all Red. I also have Rafflesias. They are all amazing.

[we4wieners]

Did you get the new fish?

I didn't yet. I went to get him and the seller got hung up in traffic and I couldn't wait. However, I am heading up next week and I prefer to have the Juru's gone before I add anymore. This will complete my stocking.

[rickztahone]

I have Rose Red, Blushing Reds, San Merahs, Curipera X's, Albino Golden Melons and Golden Melons. They are all Red. I also have Rafflesias. They are all amazing.

you know you have a favorite, spill the beans