I think it would be positive, having a more formal section to submit your fish for appraisal. Even for someone who is probably never going to take a fish to a show it would be very educational to learn if his/her fish are "in the ballpark" (i.e. would not be loughed out of the show room), in the car park of the ball park or not even in the same post code. I think the tricky thing is to judge size from a photo -would we have to use some kind of ruler? I would be happy to submit the ones amongst mine that I think look best but also the ones I think have flaws to see if the judgement matches mine and for the above mentioned educational purposes