" Critique " , please.

[alpine]

Would you all give me your critique of my young Red Melon ?

thanks,
roberto.

[alpine]

2

[jimmyhat]

very nice looking fish how young?

[alpine]

3

[bumblebee]

I would pay $60 for that, you still want my criticize?

[Tad]

IMO,
they are very nice clean melons, should grow out to be some nice fish!

regards,
Tad

[HTown Discus]

Very nice. Where are they from?

[blooddiscus]

Nice shape and color! Great discus you got there. Hope it will nicely!

[kingbashi]

they look awsome!! great shape and color!! good job--should make wonderful adults ----steve

[Spices]

Looks like a beauty to me! Keep up the great work. *A*

[ping]

Hmmm They should be in my tank
nice color and lovely shape

[chinoz]

very nice..where they from?

[chris allsop]

I would'nt mind some of them!!

[alpine]

well, you all seem to think is a nice fish. Is the shape round enough, could it be rounder ? Is the eye size large enough ? Is it red enough ? Are the fins robust enough ? what other criteria you use to critque a discus ? what do you all find the fish could have to be a better specimen ?

thanks for all the replies ,
roberto.

[gikkicat]

They look great Roberto, I am glad to see you finally got some fish. I know you are excited. How are you and the wife/

Tony