Strange breeding behavior......

[Orange Crush]

So I have 6 discus in a community tank (w/apistos and a bristlenose). One pair of discus spawn weekly and each time they get the fry to the point where they are freeswimming and attatch but within 12 hrs after that all are eaten. Okay, none of that is strange but during the last few spawns a 3rd discus starts guarding the eggs with the mom after they are laid while dad stays close by. On occassion the mom will chase off the other discus but otherwise allows it to help. I know with 100% certainty who laid the eggs because I watch it happen (okay, I'm a perv, lol). I do not know the gender of this 3rd discus since it has never spawned with another.
Why is the 3rd discus "helping"?
Why do the confirmed pair allow this?
:confused:

[John_Nicholson]

Animal behavior can be interesting to watch. Remember it is very easy to get discus to foster raise. When their hormones/instincts kick in they are very strong. The other fish is simply "wanting" to raise fry. The parents are not running it off because it does not appear to be a threat. On a slightly different note I have seen times when 2 females and 1 male would spawn together and raise the fry. I have also seen 2 males try to spawn together.

-john

[DLock3d]

I have a snakeskin that tries very hard to get fry in the next tank to attach to her. One of the setbacks of my pairs being able to see each other. At first I thought she was trying to eat the fry but when I try to do a water change she bites me. She won't lay if the other pair is on fry.

[Orange Crush]

Animal behavior can be interesting to watch. Remember it is very easy to get discus to foster raise. When their hormones/instincts kick in they are very strong. The other fish is simply "wanting" to raise fry. The parents are not running it off because it does not appear to be a threat. On a slightly different note I have seen times when 2 females and 1 male would spawn together and raise the fry. I have also seen 2 males try to spawn together.

-john
Thanks John, I take it that this behavior is not a way to help determine gender since it sounds like a male is just as likely to be the 3rd wheel as a female. Correct?

[Orange Crush]

I have a snakeskin that tries very hard to get fry in the next tank to attach to her. One of the setbacks of my pairs being able to see each other. At first I thought she was trying to eat the fry but when I try to do a water change she bites me. She won't lay if the other pair is on fry.
Wow, not even in the same tank, that is very interesting Dan. :)

[DLock3d]

It's a 75 gallon with clear glass dividers siliconed in. So, technically it is the same tank.

[John_Nicholson]

I would bet it is a male. If it was a female it would have laid eggs by now. I think it was a show in Europe where two Stendkers in different tanks tried to spawn. The female would lay eggs on the glass and the male in the tank next to her would make runs up his side. The instinct to reproduce in healthy fish can be very strong.

-john

[Orange Crush]

I would bet it is a male. If it was a female it would have laid eggs by now.
That makes sense. Thanks for the input.


I think it was a show in Europe where two Stendkers in different tanks tried to spawn. The female would lay eggs on the glass and the male in the tank next to her would make runs up his side. The instinct to reproduce in healthy fish can be very strong.
I guess so!

[DonMD]

I would bet it is a male. If it was a female it would have laid eggs by now. I think it was a show in Europe where two Stendkers in different tanks tried to spawn. The female would lay eggs on the glass and the male in the tank next to her would make runs up his side. The instinct to reproduce in healthy fish can be very strong.

-john

LMAO! A peep show!

[Poco]

I saw a similar thread by Mishka where two males and a female were making runs together, so I guess everything is possible.

[nc0gnet0]

I have had as many as 6 fish all spawning together collectively and have had two males co-operate and raise fry together (foster).

Rick

[Orange Crush]

Now that they are wrigglers they are not tolerant of the "3rd wheel". Poor discus keeps trying to help though :(

[Poco]

Glad you got the wrigglers. Which one is singled out?

[Orange Crush]

Glad you got the wrigglers. Which one is singled out?
The confirmed pair gets the fry to the point of attatchment every week but then they are eaten since it is a community tank. I really do not want any more fry (I have several dozen in a 55 I need to sell soon) otherwise I would put them in their own tank. The "3rd wheel" is the non-biological parent of the wrigglers.