Am I wrong?

[amyers]

What are the differnce between the german bred fishes and the asians? Let me have opinions.

[Northwoods Discus]

I think your wrong, LOL . I have asian fish from Kenny and Lucky and just got some of the Piwowarski fish. There are high quality fish from both markets.
Bill

[roundfishross]

this is simply bad form sir! maybe you should take it apon yourself to check into the results of the various contests held globaly!!!!

[Larry Bugg]

What are you basing that statement on? You are opening a can of worms that has been discussed here many times before. I for one would disagree with the statement. I have both German and Asian disus in my tanks. I think the quality has to do with the actual breeder not the location of the breeder. Germany has some great breeders. Asia has some great breeders.

[Skip]

Troll... We had somebody that was banned awhile start same topic.. I wonder if it same ip address

[amyers]

No Folks, Dont get me wrong , I'm simply trying to learn things from you guys with all the experience, so thats why i ask Questions. If I've hit a bad note , my humble apologies to you all.

[Skip]

Maybe u should edit ur original post... Make ur question more clear

[pcsb23]

I have moved this thread from the sponsor forum it was in as it clearly has nothing to do with that particular sponsor!

This question crops up fairly regularly on here and most other discus forums, and they usually go south in a heart beat so I'll get the warning in now! Keep it civil folks :)

[amyers]

I see that i've hit a bad note . Please kill this thread.

[flyman767]

I see that i've hit a bad note . Please kill this thread.

JUST USE THE SEARCH FUNCTION...IT'S ALL THERE!

..Ray

[Wes]

The diffrence is German ones are bred 4500 miles from the US and the Malaysains are bred 9300 miles from the US.:)

[Discus-Hans]

Okay let me start here......................... no guys don't worry, just kidding lol lol

I won't say a thing lol

Hans

[Larry Bugg]

The diffrence is German ones are bred 4500 miles from the US and the Malaysains are bred 9300 miles from the US.:)

LOL


Okay let me start here......................... no guys don't worry, just kidding lol lol

I won't say a thing lol

Hans

LMAO

[YSS]

I actually posted the same question here three years ago. I was just curious of the differences. I remember getting some good explanations. Here you go. I found it: :-) Actually, it was a poll. May be I like polls. :-)

http://forum.simplydiscus.com/showthread.php?65084-Who-s-got-the-best-discus&highlight=german

[LizStreithorst]

I wish I'd seen this thread before the first post was edited.

I know the difference between German and Asian. The differece is NOT in quality. There IS a difference. It is in the style of the fish. Which style you prefer is up to your own taste. Shoot youself. (woops, that should have been suit yourslf).

As a breeder, I have to say that crossing the two can procuce fablulos offspring. Hybird vigor and all that, you know...These lines have been seperate for so many generations.

[Larry Bugg]

I actually posted the same question here three years ago. [/url]

Actually the question is completely different than when first posted.