Separate undergrown pair or remain in shoal "as is"?

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Contrarian
    Registered Member
    • Jul 2019
    • 56
    • Austin, TX

    #1

    Separate undergrown pair or remain in shoal "as is"?

    Hey everyone! I'm looking for firsthand experience from those who have managed larger schools of discus, preferably at least 10, but ideally 20–30+ fish or more.

    I have a school of 30 young adult Super Red Melon discus, approximately 2 years old, that have been raised together since they were around 2–3 inches. Most have developed and grown nicely, but two have fallen significantly behind.

    Apologies for the poor picture quality and reflections in the video. You can probably identify the two fish that are noticeably smaller and whose coloration is off.

    Pics attached & here is a video:



    Both experience bullying from the larger fish during feeding. They still eat, but I suspect they're not getting enough food to thrive or catch up.

    One thing I've noticed with these hybrids is how territorial they can become during feeding. Standing your ground and fighting back seems essential to avoid being bullied, regardless of size. The aggression almost seems contagious. Unfortunately, neither of these two fish stands up for itself. They begin eating but are repeatedly pushed away before getting enough.

    Here's my dilemma:

    Would separating these two into a dedicated grow-out tank for 2–3 months, where they could feed without competition, improve their chances of developing?

    Or would removing them from the school they've known their entire lives create additional stress and potentially make matters worse?

    I'm genuinely on the fence and particularly interested in firsthand experiences rather than theoretical advice.

    If you've managed a larger school and encountered this situation, I'd appreciate hearing:
    • How many discus were in your school & did you separate the underdeveloped fish or leave them with the group?
    • If separated, did they demonstrate meaningful growth, improved coloration, and overall recovery?
    • How long did you keep them separated, and were you successful reintroducing them into the original school?

    I'm equally interested in hearing about unsuccessful attempts. Knowing what didn't work can be just as valuable.

    Thanks in advance for sharing your experience.
    You may only view thumbnails in this gallery. This gallery has 7 photos.
  • danotaylor
    Registered Member + MVP
    • May 2018
    • 4412
    • Aussie living in Cincy
    • Daniel

    #2
    I recently euthanized 2 of my discus in a group of 11 d/t excessive bullying resulting in failure to thrive. These were adult discus in the 5.5-6.5” range. Both fish would also eat but get bullied at meal times and in general. I would hand feed them on my days off, and actually bullied the rest of the group with my hand to ensure the 2 weaker fish got food. Despite these efforts both continued to lose condition. My feeling was that the evidence of failure to thrive was not just bullying at feeding time, but a general sense of fear related to their place at the bottom of the pecking order. Both fish were also albino and it did appear that their eyesight was a factor in their feeding approach. I tried low light, no light scenarios both both fish literally appeared blind to me at times.
    After watching them appear to suffer for several months, and knowing they wouldn’t do well if separated to a tank by themselves I made the (humane) decision to euthanize them.
    At 2 years of age the rapid growth phase is well and truly over. At this point d/t the stressors these fish are living under, it would be highly unlikely that they could reach their genetic potential, even if separated.
    I will say the smaller of the 2 you are talking about, at the end of the video, shows very swollen gills, where the gill plates do not even return to normal position between respirations. This fish in particular looks miserable.
    Last edited by danotaylor; 10-31-2026, 10:22 PM.

    Comment

    • Contrarian
      Registered Member
      • Jul 2019
      • 56
      • Austin, TX

      #3
      I appreciate you sharing. These guys arent miserable at this point. The issue is not if they have bodily functions but socially they aren't able to stick up for themselves and as aresult don't get as much food.
      Since they both see okay and are able to get food I wanted to inquire as I had read about others separating those fish either perm or temp depending on many conditions but no follow up as to if they benefited. This pair can forage & eat so I'm not quite ready to euthanize esp. when I have an excellent tank I can move both of them to. I was curious if others had faced this before with undersized yet healthy specimens and what they chose to do. Thanks again for sharing!

      Comment

      • danotaylor
        Registered Member + MVP
        • May 2018
        • 4412
        • Aussie living in Cincy
        • Daniel

        #4
        I’m not tryna be critical, but this is far from a healthy fish.

        Click image for larger version

Name:	IMG_8428.png
Views:	31
Size:	106.3 KB
ID:	2779901
        If you want it to have any chance of survival you will have to remove it from it current social group.

        Comment

        • chelltom
          Registered Member
          • Dec 2019
          • 424
          • North Mississippi / Memphis
          • Tom

          #5
          Agreed I would remove them and hit with a round of metro and salt treatment also high temps and feed small amounts at least 3 times a day. Worse case you lose them , but there is a chance you may turn them around .

          Comment

          • chelltom
            Registered Member
            • Dec 2019
            • 424
            • North Mississippi / Memphis
            • Tom

            #6
            after the metro lets take another look for consideration ...

            Comment

            • Contrarian
              Registered Member
              • Jul 2019
              • 56
              • Austin, TX

              #7
              100% agree. I wouldn't have brought it to the SD group if I didn't agree something must be done. That's why I posted.

              I agree with the heat, salt and metro. I'll address and repost after a few days.
              Last edited by Contrarian; 11-02-2026, 11:40 PM.

              Comment

              Working...